Jeffrey I. Carton - White Plains, NY

Overview

Jeff has been recognized annually by his peers as one of the Top 25 New York "Super Lawyers" in Westchester County and repeatedly chosen as one of US News & World Report's "Best Lawyers in America" in the area of commercial litigation. He has also been selected as a lifetime member of "Elite Lawyers in America," "The Multi-Million Dollar Advocates Forum," and "Top Trial Lawyers in America," and inducted as a Fellow into both the prestigious Litigation Counsel of America and the venerable American Bar Association Foundation.

Jeff's versatility in the Courtroom and dexterity with a wide array of subject matters has led to his handling of many high profile, difficult cases. Among other matters, Jeff successfully led the defense in federal court of a boat-builder wrongfully implicated in the "Ethan Allen" tragedy on Lake George in which twenty persons perished, winning summary judgment on the client's behalf; argued before the New Jersey Supreme Court the landmark consumer fraud class action, Lee v. Basic Research, which resulted in a unanimous, 9-0 opinion overturning the lower courts' decisions denying class certification; argued before the Massachusetts' Supreme Judicial Court the precedent setting case of Tyler v. Michaels which declared unlawful the collection of personal identifying information in connection with retail credit card transactions; and successfully prosecuted the highly publicized "Borgata Babes" employment discrimination action against the Borgata Casino in Atlantic City. Jeff's reputation for excellent results and dogged preparation, make him a formidable adversary.

Jeff has also successfully tried to verdict a diverse number of matters, including securing a defense verdict for Madison Square Garden and Amtrak in a federal jury trial in the Eastern District of New York; winning a multi-million dollar jury award in a state court breach of contract action in White Plains; prevailing in a nine month real estate fraud arbitration in New York City in which he recovered a multi-million dollar judgment; and obtaining a $4.5 million jury verdict in Columbia County against Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute (RPI).

Jeff's experience in the sports, media and entertainment industries has also allowed for his successful handling of a variety of matters including claims of copyright infringement, trademark infringement, breach of television Executive Production Agreements, royalty disputes, and artist-management conflicts. Jeff has advised television broadcast journalists, senior media executives and executive producers on a wide range of issues concerning non-competes, first amendment rights, and compensation and severance disputes.

Jeff led the successful prosecution of the wrongful death action of Baltimore Orioles' pitcher Steve Bechler, helped extricate former light heavyweight World Champion boxer Reggie Johnson from an onerous promoter's contract, and counseled the Estate of Tito Puente, the Latin Salsa King, in a misappropriation of name and likeness litigation. Jeff also spearheaded the successful prosecution of the United States Tennis Association's (USTA) multimillion dollar breach of contract action against a sponsor of the US Open, as well as defended the USTA against a claim of disability discrimination which he successfully had dismissed, and successfully represented Heineken in a breach of contract action arising from a marketing services agreement. Jeff regularly counsels media and entertainment clients in contract negotiations, severance disputes, and intellectual property matters.

Jeff's skill with complex litigation has also allowed him to develop significant experience handling a diverse array of maritime and admiralty matters. Jeff has successfully defended boat builders, marinas, charter vessels, stevedores and other marine interests in both federal and state litigations throughout the Country. Among other successful outcomes, Jeff defended a boat builder wrongfully implicated in the Ethan Allen tragedy on Lake George; defended a marine terminal operator in a federal wrongful death action in Portland, Maine; represented a luxury yacht manufacturer in a premises liability action in federal court in New Jersey; defended a Manhattan sight-seeing tour operator against a personal injury claim; and handled a Society of Maritime Arbitrators (SMA) arbitration concerning the scope of a contractual indemnity between a terminal operator and a multinational transport company.

Jeff is a cum laude graduate of Dartmouth College, a graduate of Columbia Law School and began his career as a litigator at Cravath Swaine & Moore.